September 27, 2012

Prosecutor: Sex proved Mercier killed St. Peter; defense attorney says there is 'reasonable doubt'

SKOWHEGAN — Sex may not be murder, but sex in this case proved murder over and over again, according to prosecutor Andrew Benson in his closing arguments in the Jay Mercier murder trial this morning.

The evidence that Mercier, 57, of Industry killed 20-year-old Rita St. Peter in 1980 is overwhelming, according Benson, an assistant attorney general.

"This is not a whodunnit. We know very well who did it. It was Jay Mercier. He was on the prowl and Rita St. Peter was an easy target," Benson told jurors in Somerset County Superior Court.

click image to enlarge

Staff photo by David Leaming DEFENSE: Murder defendant Jay Mercier sits between defense attorneys John Alsop, left, and John Mitchell during Mercier's trial in the death of Rita St. Peter being held at Somerset County Superior Court in Skowhegan this week.

click image to enlarge

Staff photo by David Leaming EVIDENCE: Assistant Attorney General Andrew Benson presents evidence to the jury during opening statements in the trial of jay Mercier in Somerset County Superior Court in Skowhegan on Thursday.

Mercier is charged in the beating death of the Anson woman.

In his closing argument, defense attorney John Alsop told the jury that there is enough reasonable doubt in the 32-year-old murder of  St. Peter to find his client not guilty of murder.

Sometimes in life, Alsop told the jury, "We simply don't know the answers. This is one of those times."

Alsop said evidence becomes lost or degrades or disappears over the years.

"The expiration date on this case is an issue," he said.

Somerset County Superior Court Justice John Nivison gave his final instructions to the jury just before noon today. Two jury alternates were released from duty, leaving seven women and five men to determine guilt or innocence.

Mercier faces 25 years to life in  prison if he is found guilty.

Defense attorneys Alsop and John Martin rested their case in Somerset County Superior Court Wednesday after they called six witnesses. Mercier did not testify.

The prosecution concluded its case earlier in the morning.

Witnesses for the defense testified that they saw the victim, Rita St. Peter, on July 4, 1980, and that she had been drinking at a bar in downtown Madison and by late that night was highly intoxicated.

Robert Jacobs of Anson testified that he also saw Mercier, who had been drinking, but he never saw Mercier and St. Peter together.

Another witness, Roxanne Collins, told the jury that she and her husband saw St. Peter at the bar, and that St. Peter's jeans were ripped up the back seam and she needed a sweatshirt to cover up.

Earlier testimony for the prosecution indicated that when police found St. Peter's body, her jeans were ripped.

William Garland of Anson testified that the area where St. Peter's body was found was a popular party spot that local residents called the passion pit.

Wednesday afternoon, with the jury out of the room, Alsop made a motion for acquittal, which he noted is common in criminal cases but different in Mercier's trial because it is a 32-year-old murder case.

"There are no safeguards against lost records, lost evidence and lost memories," Alsop said. "We have to be doubly sure the evidence is reliable."

Alsop said DNA evidence produced in the case may show that Mercier had sex with St. Peter, but there is no evidence that Mercier killed her.

Mercier was a suspect from the beginning, but consistently denied killing St. Peter. He also denied ever having known her, denied giving her a ride in his truck and denied having sex with her, despite the fact that his DNA was found on her.

"Can a jury convict someone of murder based on his denial of sexual activity?" Alsop asked. "They cannot conclude that he denied having sex with her so he therefore murdered her."

(Continued on page 2)

Were you interviewed for this story? If so, please fill out our accuracy form

Send question/comment to the editors

Further Discussion

Here at we value our readers and are committed to growing our community by encouraging you to add to the discussion. To ensure conscientious dialogue we have implemented a strict no-bullying policy. To participate, you must follow our Terms of Use.

Questions about the article? Add them below and we’ll try to answer them or do a follow-up post as soon as we can. Technical problems? Email them to us with an exact description of the problem. Make sure to include:
  • Type of computer or mobile device your are using
  • Exact operating system and browser you are viewing the site on (TIP: You can easily determine your operating system here.)